prop firms judge
EDITORIAL POLICY

Evidence before a score.

Prop Firms Judge publishes a comparison of futures prop firm accounts. Our purpose is to make the cost, constraints and differences between trading phases easier to inspect.

Who publishes this research?

The publisher is Prop Firms Judge. This is an independent comparison project, not a prop firm, broker or regulator. The catalogue is not proof that a firm pays reliably or that a trader will pass.

Sources you can check

Each researched field keeps its official source link, the date it was read and any caveat. A general sales page and a detailed policy can disagree: contradictions must remain visible until resolved. Missing facts stay unconfirmed, rather than becoming zero fees or unrestricted trading.

A publication date is not a new verification of every source. Review-due dates are targets; automatic weekly research is not running. Prices and promotions can change before a scheduled review.

One account, different phases

Evaluation, simulated funded and live rules are kept separate. Direct entry does not necessarily mean live capital. Legacy and current programmes do not inherit one another’s conditions.

We distinguish when a drawdown threshold moves from when it is enforced. A floor calculated at the end of the day may still fail an account during an open trade.

What the judgement measures

Tile marks run from 1 to 10, with higher meaning more favourable within the observed numerical range. Comparisons require the same product kind, drawdown model, daily-loss option, nominal size and availability category; price comparisons additionally separate billing and verified deadlines, and entry prices separate activation-fee presence. We do not widen a group to obtain a score. Equal observed values receive a neutral range position, not a claim of quality. The partial Eval comparison in the detailed tiles covers cost to funded, monthly renewal where applicable, and target/drawdown; every applicable criterion must be comparable. The partial combined result uses the intersection of the criterion cohorts and recalculates each range within that shared group. Its weakest unrounded position determines the result: cheaper entry cannot compensate for a worse target/loss ratio or renewal. Map that position to 1–10 and round once; if every criterion is tied, the result is 6/10. This does not establish a complete Evaluation judgment. Fewer than two common accounts means no aggregate. Individual tile ranges can differ.

The board’s global Evaluation judgment uses three groups: paid-horizon cost, risk and trading constraints. Each group gives its criteria equal weight, and the lowest group determines the result. A complete comparative grade requires supported comparisons for all declared criteria; missing criteria instead widen the range. Identical, documented policies can tie even when the firm has not published a numeric threshold. For Alpha Standard and Advanced of the same size, the risk/reward tie compares the published restriction on maximum-leverage account rolling. It does not infer a permitted ratio or trade approval. Monthly comparisons model three paid periods plus activation, excluding resets, taxes, optional charges and commissions. The Builder 50K Funded pilot compares the two loss-limit options. The board shows the first payout cycle and the expanded details compare cycles 2–5 separately. The first cycle measures initial loss room and first-request conditions. Later cycles assess the fresh profit requirement and fixed threshold separately from remaining loss room. Other criteria remain open across the 1–10 scale, and the lowest group determines the range. The Builder 50K Live pilot compares published invitation milestones, risk conditions and withdrawal rules. Fees, actual opening capital and approval remain open. The LucidFlex and LucidPro Funded comparison covers the first cycle at 25K, 50K, 100K and 150K with DLL off. It separates winning-day rules, consistency and the protected payout buffer. Disputed caps and actual retained loss room remain open. The Alpha Standard and Zero Funded comparison covers the base plans at 50K and 100K. It compares first-cycle request minimums and caps separately and leaves the exact 40% consistency boundary unresolved. These Funded and Live ranges are partial. The separate difficulty view uses a 1–5 index, where higher means harder. It assigns editorial severity and weights to individual constraints: drawdown, loss enforcement, daily limits, sizing, consistency and other documented restrictions. Passing, preserving an account and withdrawing profits are different problems.

Open the phase details to see which criteria count and their weights. We calculate the weighted average within each group, then use the lowest group for the phase. For each unresolved criterion, the lower bound uses 1 and the upper bound uses 10. An interval can collapse to one value when a documented group already limits both bounds. The result stays pending while a required criterion is unresolved.

In the separate difficulty view, an unscored constraint defaults to 1–5. An explicitly labelled conditional partial bound can narrow that range under the stated editorial assumption. It remains unscored: exact contributions and fully-known weight are not added, and source caveats stay visible.

A range is not a prediction of your chance of passing. Relative marks depend on the comparison group, and a favourable mark does not establish profitability or suitability for a particular strategy. Open the board’s judgement detail for the current model, factors and evidence coverage.

The Apex Legacy MAE check uses a confirmed regime and a supplied open loss. The separate Legacy 5:1 check compares a planned stop distance with its target. These checks sit outside the overall assessment. The field audit identifies these gaps. Live-account transitions and the combined effect of every trading rule are not fully simulated.

Check an account against your requirements

On the account board, set the limits you need for Evaluation, Funded and Live. A phase fits when the documented values meet all the limits you selected. A confirmed miss puts it outside your limits. Missing or conflicting evidence stays unresolved. Open the phase verdict to see each comparison and the dated source.

The Evaluation budget uses the documented base entry for one attempt or first billing period plus activation. The base target can rise under consistency rules. Funded and Live share checks use a single flat trader percentage. A holding check uses the trading-session close and applies a shared rule only when its source explicitly covers the phase. The Live route check describes how an account is offered. It does not guarantee a transfer or withdrawal.

Affiliate links and commercial independence

Links labelled Affiliate may earn us a commission. Other links open the firm’s official website. Affiliate relationships do not change our scores or sort order. An affiliate link alone does not establish the size or availability of a discount: confirm the final offer at checkout.

Official research citations remain source links, not affiliate redirects. Logos identify the firm and do not imply endorsement.

Corrections and limitations

The linked official policy and applicable account agreement should be checked before purchase. If you find a discrepancy, retain the exact configuration, rule, source URL and date so it can be checked. We do not currently provide a public correction submission form.

This research is educational information, not personalised investment advice. Fees may be lost; simulated performance and nominal balances do not establish real-market returns.

Explore the sourced firm guides →